Re: WXV Trade Confirmation Thread & Final Draft Order

[Purple 77]

Round   Pick   Club
1   1   Dublin Wellington
1   2   New York Pacific Wellington
1   3   Berlin Moscow Beijing
1   4   PNL Tokyo
1   5   Cairo Pacific Dublin Toronto Buenos Aires New York Wellington Pacific
1   6   Tokyo Pacific
1   7   Pacific New Delhi Pacific New York Mexico City New Delhi
1   8   New Delhi Cairo London
1   9   London
1   10   Seoul Berlin Pacific New Delhi Mexico City New York Moscow Dublin
1   11   Beijing
1   12   Wellington
1   13   Toronto Tokyo Berlin Mexico City Beijing
1   14   Moscow Tokyo Toronto Beijing Moscow Toronto New Delhi Mexico City Beijing
1   15   Buenos Aires Cape Town New York
1   16   Sao Paulo
1   17   Cape Town New Delhi
1   18   Mexico City New Delhi Cairo Mexico City
PP   19   Dublin Beijing
2   20   Dublin London
2   21   New York Tokyo Moscow Beijing Mexico City
2   22   Berlin London Moscow Beijing
2   23   PNL Tokyo
2   24   Cairo Moscow Dublin
2   25   Tokyo Berlin Wellington
2   26   Pacific Sao Paulo Tokyo Moscow Cairo New Delhi New York
2   27   New Delhi Cape Town
2   28   London Seoul Beijing
2   29   Seoul Beijing Berlin Wellington
2   30   Beijing Dublin Berlin Moscow Beijing Moscow Dublin
2   31   Wellington Sao Paulo
2   32   Toronto Sao Paulo New York
2   33   Moscow Berlin New York Cairo Seoul
2   34   Buenos Aires PNL
2   35   Sao Paulo Tokyo
2   36   Cape Town London Seoul
2   37   Mexico City Wellington Pacific Berlin
3   38   Dublin Berlin Pacific
3   39   New York Pacific Toronto
3   40   Berlin
3   41   PNL Wellington
3   42   Cairo Moscow Sao Paulo Cairo Wellington
3   43   Tokyo Toronto Tokyo
3   44   Pacific New York Berlin Toronto Cairo
3   45   New Delhi Pacific Berlin London
3   46   London Pacific Mexico City
3   47   Seoul Tokyo
3   48   Beijing Tokyo
3   49   Wellington
3   50   Toronto Berlin Cairo Toronto
3   51   Moscow Cairo Buenos Aires Mexico City Beijing
3   52   Buenos Aires Mexico City Cairo Seoul
3   53   Sao Paulo Toronto Tokyo
3   54   Cape Town
3   55   Mexico City Beijing
4   56   Dublin Buenos Aires
4   57   New York Pacific
4   58   Berlin Tokyo
4   59   PNL New York Beijing Wellington
4   60   Cairo Pacific Berlin
4   61   Tokyo Toronto
4   62   Pacific
4   63   New Delhi Cairo Berlin
4   64   London Berlin
4   65   Seoul Beijing
4   66   Beijing
4   67   Wellington
4   68   Toronto Dublin Berlin
4   69   Moscow Berlin
4   70   Buenos Aires
4   71   Sao Paulo Pacific Toronto Berlin
4   72   Cape Town
4   73   Mexico City
5   74   Dublin Buenos Aires
5   75   New York Buenos Aires
5   76   Berlin Moscow Mexico City Beijing
5   77   PNL Moscow London
5   78   Cairo Cape Town Berlin
5   79   Tokyo
5   80   Pacific New York
5   81   New Delhi Cairo
5   82   London
5   83   Seoul Cairo
5   84   Beijing
5   85   Wellington
5   86   Toronto Buenos Aires
5   87   Moscow Beijing
5   88   Buenos Aires New York
5   89   Sao Paulo London
5   90   Cape Town
5   91   Mexico City New Delhi



Trades Made in Week One (to be voted upon)


Note - Confirmed means all parties have agreed to it but has yet to be accepted by the group.

Green: Approved

Red: Blocked


Trade 1 (Confirmed)
New York Gives: Picks 2, 21, 39 and 57, Nick O'Brien, Alex Fasolo
New York Receives: Pick 80, Travis Cloke, Trent McKenzie, Ayce Cordy

Tokyo Gives: Pick 6, Trent McKenzie, Sam Blease, Travis Cloke, Ayce Cordy
Tokyo Receives: Pick 21, Chris Judd, Nick Suban, Jacob Townsend, Alex Fasolo, Nick O'Brien

Pacific Gives: Pick 80, Chris Judd, Nick Suban, Jacob Townsend
Pacific Receives: Picks 2, 6, 39 and 57, Sam Blease

Trade 2 (Confirmed)
London Gives: Bob Murphy
Moscow Gives: Jonathan Brown

Trade 3 (Confirmed)
Sao Paulo Gives: Pick 53, Sam Fisher
Toronto Gives: Pick 32, Taylor Adams

Trade 4 (Confirmed)
Sao Paulo Gives: Daniel Cross
New Delhi Gives: Matthew Buntine and Jared Polec

Trade 5 (Confirmed)
Berlin Gives: Brent Moloney
Mexico City Gives: Daniel Talia

Trade 6 (Confirmed)
Mexico City Gives: Terry Milera and Kyle Reimers
New Delhi Gives: Daniel Merrett and Brent Harvey

Trade 7 (Confirmed)
Seoul Gives: Ryan Griffen
Cairo Gives: Josh J Kennedy

Trade 8 (Confirmed)
Dublin Gives: Shane Mumford, Callan Ward, Nick Malceski
Cairo Gives: Todd Goldstein, Jack Redden, Adam Tomlinson

Trade 9 (Confirmed)
Sao Paulo Gives: Pick 71 and Jarryd Blair
Pacific Gives: Pick 26 and Andrew Walker

Trade 10 (Confirmed)
Beijing Gives: Pick 30 and Mitch Clark
Dublin Gives: Pick 19 and Josh Caddy

Trade 11 (Confirmed)
Seoul Gives: Brent Renouf and Ben Rutten
New Delhi Gives: Brett Ebert

Trade 12 (Confirmed)
Cairo Gives: Pick 60 and Jordan Lisle
Pacific Gives: Josh Gibson

Trade 13 (Confirmed)
Tokyo Gives: Sam Rowe and Koby Stevens
Cairo Gives: Shaun Hampson

Trade 14 (Confirmed)
Sao Paulo Gives: Picks 26, 35 and Steven Motlop
Tokyo Gives: Jack Gunston

Trade 15 (Confirmed)
Seoul Gives: Pick 10 and Jack Steven
Berlin Gives: Preseason Draft Pick 3, Paul Duffield, Liam Patrick and Seb Ross

Trade 16 (Confirmed)
Cairo Gives: Pick 5, Leigh Montagna and Clinton Young
Cairo Receives: Pick 8 and Drew Petrie

Pacific Gives: Pick 7, Drew Petrie and Lee Spurr
Pacific Receives: Picks 5, 45 and Tom Rockliff

New Delhi Gives: Picks 8, 45, and Tom Rockliff
New Delhi Receives: Pick 7, Leigh Montagna, Clinton Young and Lee Spurr

Trade 17 (Confirmed)
London gives: Michael Hurley
London receives: Picks 20, 22

Dublin gives: Picks 20, 30, 38
Dublin receives: Michael Hurley

Berlin gives: Pick 22
Berlin receives: Picks 30, 38

Trade 18 (Confirmed)
Cape Town gives: Lindsay Thomas
Cairo gives: Pick 78, Jacob Brennan

Trade 19 (Confirmed)
Seoul gives: Pick 65
Beijing gives: Jay Lever

Trade 20 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Nat Fyfe, Jack Darling
Moscow gives: Allen Christensen, Ryan Bastinac, Tom Liberatore

Trade 21 (Confirmed)
Tokyo gives: Picks 21, 26
Moscow Gives: Pick 14

Trade 22 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Picks 26, 51 and Harley Bennell
Cairo gives: Pick 42 and Ryan Griffen

Trade 23 (Confirmed)
PNL gives: Pick 41, Tendai Mzungu
Wellington gives: Elliot Kavanagh, Jared Brennan

Trade 24 (Confirmed)
Cape Town gives: Jack Grimes
Buenos Aires gives: Pick 15, Billie Smedts and Nathan Vardy

Trade 25 (Confirmed)
Buenos Aires give: 2nd round Preseason Draft pick and Dane Swan, Matthew Boyd, Shannon Hurn, Heath Scotland and Stewart Crameri
Buenos Aires receive: Pick 1, Ben Howlett, Brad Ebert, Brock McLean, Nathan Foley, Garrick Ibbotson, Scott D. Thompson

Mexico City gives: Pick 18, Ben Howlett, Brad Ebert, Brock McLean, Nathan Foley, Garrick Ibbotson
Mexico City receives: 2nd round Preseason Draft pick, Dane Swan, Matthew Boyd, Shannon Hurn, Heath Scotland

Dublin gives: Pick 1 and Scott D Thompson
Dublin receives: Pick 18 and Stewart Crameri

Trade 26 (Confirmed)
New Delhi gives: Nick Dal Santo
Cairo gives: Pick 26 and Josh Gibson

Trade 27 (Confirmed)
Cairo gives: Pick 8 and Josh Hill
London gives: Luke Breust

Trade 28 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Terry Milera, Jarrad Boumann, Kyle Reimers
New Delhi gives: Brent Harvey, Daniel Merrett

Trade 29 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Pick 68, Nathan van Berlo and Josh Bootmas
Dublin gives: Nathan Grima

Trade 30 (Confirmed)
Seoul gives: Harry O'Brien
London gives: Pick 28 and Shannon Byrnes

Trade 31 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Picks 33, 69, Thomas Lynch and Brandon Matera
Berlin gives: Picks 3, 30, 76 and Michael Walters

Trade 32 (Confirmed)
Cairo gives: Chris Masten
Sao Paulo gives: Pick 42 & Jon Griffin

Trade 33 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Pick 3
Beijing gives: Dom Tyson

Trade 34 (Confirmed)
Pacific gives: Pick 44 and Dion Prestia
New York gives: Claye Beams and Ben Cunnington

Trade 35 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Pick 33 and Will Schofield
New York gives: Pick 44 and Stefan Martin

Trade 36 (Confirmed)
Wellington gives: Alex Rance and Brandon Ellis
Wellington receives: Pick 1 and Adam Schneider

Dublin gives: Picks 1, 56 and 74, Scott D. Thompson and Adam Schneider
Dublin receives: Travis Boak, Brandon Ellis and Alex Rance

Buenos Aires gives: Travis Boak
Buenos Aires receives: Picks 56 & 74, Scott D. Thompson

Trade 37 (Confirmed)
London gives: Pick 46 & Sam Docherty
Pacific gives: Quinten Lynch

Trade 38 (Confirmed)
London gives: Brad Sheppard & Stephen Hill
Sao Paulo gives: Pick 89, Dan Hanneberry and Zach Touhy

Trade 39 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Pick 53, Jared Rivers & Ted Richards
Tokyo gives: Pick 43 & Liam Shiels

Trade 40 (Confirmed)
New Delhi gives: Corey Enright & Jordan Murdoch
Tokyo gives: Pick 14

Trade 41 (Confirmed)
Cairo gives: Sharrod Wellingham
New Delhi gives: Picks 63, 81 and Jarryn Geary

Trade 42 (Confirmed)
Buenos Aires gives: Jared Petrenko and Ben Jacobs
Cairo gives: Pick 51 and Drew Petrie

Trade 43 (Confirmed)
Sao Paulo gives: Josh Growden
Moscow gives: Pick 42

Trade 44 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Picks 10, 38, Jeremy Howe and Sam Darley
Pacific gives: Picks 45, 60 and David Swallow

Trade 45 (Confirmed)
Pacific gives: Simon Black, Daniel Kerr and Pick 46
Mexico City gives: Ben Howlett

Trade 46 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Josh Green
Dublin gives: Pick 68, Rookie Pick 37, Lachie Neale

Trade 47 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Pick 18
New Delhi gives: Corey Enright

Trade 48 (Confirmed)
Pacific gives: Pick 5 and Sam Docherty
Dublin gives: Billy Longer and Adam Tomlinson

Trade 49 (Confirmed)
Pacific gives: Pick 10 + Lewis Roberts-Thomson
New Delhi gives: Pick 7

Trade 50 (Confirmed)
Tokyo gives: Picks 14, 61 and Matt Leuenberger
Toronto gives: Picks 13, 43 and Sam Mitchell

Trade 51 (Confirmed)
Cairo gives: Matt Rosa
Beijing gives: Shaun Grigg

Trade 52 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Pick 14, Preseason Draft 2nd Round and Liam Shiels
Beijing gives: Andrew swallow

Trade 53 (Confirmed)
Pacific gives: Picks 39, 71, Darren Jolly, Ben Cunnington and Levi Greenwood
Toronto gives: Matt Leuenberger

Trade 54 (Confirmed)
London gives: Pick 22
Moscow gives: Steven Morris

Trade 55 (Confirmed)
Seoul gives: Picks 28, 29 and Preseason Draft Pick 3
Beijing gives: Clancee Pearce

Trade 56 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Pick 37 and Nathan Foley
Wellington gives: Scott Thompson (Crows)

Trade 57 (Confirmed)
Welling gives: Sam Butler
Toronto gives: Rohan Bewick

Trade 58 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Chris Knights
Mexico City gives: James Sellar

Trade 59 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Pick 33, Ryan Bastinac, Bernie Vince, Michael Rischitelli, Kyal Horsley, Lewis Johnston
Cairo gives: Harley Bennell, Koby Stevens and Hayden Crozier

Trade 60 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Mark Seaby
London gives: Pick 64


Trade 61 (Confirmed)
Buenos Aires gives: Pick 34, Stewart Crameri, Clay Smith, Robert Warnock, Justin Westhoff and Daniel Nicholson
PNL gives: Pick 59, Matthew Pavlich, Steve Johnson and Adam Selwood


Trade 62 (Confirmed)
PNL gives: George Horlin-Smith
New Delhi gives: Jackson Trengove

Trade 63 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Pick 87
Beijing gives: Liam Jurrah

Trade  64 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Picks 22 and 30
Beijing gives: Shane Tuck

Trade 65 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Trent West and Pick 58
Tokyo gives: Picks 13, 25

Trade 66 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Steven Verrier
Buenos Aires gives: Pick 88

Trade 67 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Kyle Hardingham
Moscow gives: Jordan Russell

Trade 68 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Pick 76
Mexico City gives: Josh Mellington

Trade 69 (Confirmed)
New Delhi gives: Pick 10
Mexico City gives: Garrick Ibbotson, Simon Black, Martin Mattner and Matthew White

Trade 70 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Ayce Cordy
PNL gives: Pick 59 + Jackson Paine

Trade 71 (Confirmed)
Ney York gives: Pick 59
Beijing gives: Mitch Morton

Trade 72 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Matthew Panos
PNL gives: Pick 77

Trade 73 (Confirmed)
Buenos Aires gives: Pick 34 + Clay Smith, Justin Westhoff, Brad McKenzie
PNL gives: Steve Johnson and Jared Brennan

Trade 74 (Confirmed)
New Delhi gives: Dayne Zorko
Pacific gives: Pick 38 + Sam Gibson, Cameron Wood

Trade 75 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Paul Chapman and Brent Harvey
Buenos Aires gives: Picks 51, 52 and Stewart Crameri

Trade 76 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Matt de Boer, Ahmed Saad, Jackson Paine and Shane Savage
Pacific gives: Pick 7 and Jarryd Blair

Trade 77 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Shaun Burgoyne
Mexico City receives: Pick 13

Berlin gives: Pick 13 + Jack Watts
Berlin receives: Jack Grimes

Dublin gives: Michael Barlow
Dublin receives: Jack Watts + Jese Stringer

Buenos Aires gives: Jack Grimes + Jesse Stringer
Buenos Aires receive: Michael Barlow + Shaun Burgoyne

Trade 78 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Picks 55 and 76
Beijing gives: Brian Lake

Trade 79 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Tory Dickson
Cairo gives: Bernie Vince

Trade 80 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Pick 52
Cairo gives: Aaron Young

Trade 81 (Confirmed)
Mexico City gives: Pick 10 + Aaron Young
New York gives: Pick 7

Trade 82 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Brodie Smith, Mitch Brown and Ben Sinclair
New York gives: Pick 10 and Jack Hombsch

Trade 83 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Pick 10
Dublin gives: Brandon Ellis

Trade 84 (Confirmed)
Tokyo gives: Phil Davis and Jonathon Patton
PNL gives: Picks 4 and 23

Trade 85 (Confirmed)
Seoul gives: Pick 47 and Seb Ross
Tokyo gives: Heath Hocking

Trade 86 (Confirmed)
Beijing gives: Pick 48
Tokyo gives: Neville Jetta

Trade 87 (Confirmed)
Cape Town gives: Pick 36 and Sam Iles
London gives: Jeff Garlett

Trade 88 (Confirmed)
Moscow gives: Pick 21 and Sam Kerridge
Beijing gives: Picks 14 and 30

Trade 89 (Confirmed)
London gives: Fraser McInness
Moscow gives: Pick 77, Tom Young and Nathan Wilson

Trade 90 (Confirmed)
Seoul gives: Preseason Draft Pick 10 and Shannon Byrnes
Wellington gives: Joel Corey

Trade 91 (Confirmed)
Wellington gives: Pick 31
Sao Paulo gives: Rory Thompson

Trade 92 (Unconfirmed)
Beijing gives: Pick 59
Wellington gives: Aaron Cornelius

Trade 93 (Confirmed)
Berlin gives: Lachie Neal
Beijing gives: Pick 29

Trade 94 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Picks 50 + 71
Berlin gives: Pick 44

Trade 95 (Confirmed)
London gives: Rory Laird, Daniel Gorringe and Andrew Mackie
Beijing gives: Steele Sidebottom

Trade 96 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Robbie Gray and Kieran Harper
Dublin gives: Pick 5 and Tommy Walsh

Trade 97 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Pick 5 and Andrew Carrazzo
Buenos Aires gives: Mitch Robinson and Dan Nicholson

Trade 98 (Confirmed)
New York gives: Pick 75 and Dean Cox
Buenos Aires gives: Pick 5 and Josh Jenkins

Trade 99 (Confirmed)
Wellington gives: Jonathan Giles
New York gives: Pick 5

Trade 100 (Confirmed)
Toronto gives: Pick 61, Sam Fisher and Angus Monfries
New Delhi gives: Jordan Murdoch

Trade 101 (Unconfirmed)
Cairo gives: Pick 42, Sean Dempster and Andrew Krakouer
Wellington gives: Jed Adcock

Trade 102 Confirmed
Dublin give: Israel Folau
Moscow give: Pick 30

Trade 103 Confirmed
Mexico gives: Daniel Kerr + Alan Toovey + Henry Schade + Pick 13 + Pick 46 + Pick 51
Beijing gives: Steele Sidebottom

Trade 104 Confirmed
Moscow gives: Pick 14
Toronto gives: Angus Monfries

Trade 105 Confirmed
Seoul gives: Matthew Warnock and Tom Lonergan
London gives: Pick 36

Trade 106  Confirmed
Toronto gives: Sam Fisher, Pick 14 and Josh Toy
New Delhi gives: Dayne Zorko and Ben Mabon

Trade 107 Confirmed
Toronto gives: Sam Wright and Ben Hudson
London gives: Richard Douglas and Steven Morris

Trade 108 Confirmed
Toronto gives: Pick 86
Beunos Aires gives: David Rodan

Trade 109
Mexico gives: Picks 7 and 91
New Delhi gives: Pick 14 and Daniel Cross

Trade 110
Mexico gives: Pick 13, Pick 14, Pick 51, Daniel Kerr, Alan Toovey and Henry Schade.
Beijing gives: Steele Sidebottom and Pick 21

Trade 111
Berlin Gives: Pick 25, Pick 29, Tom Couch and Tom Downie
Wellington Gives: Reece Conca + Jack Fitzpatrick

Trade 112
Sao Paulo Pumas Trades: ND #32
New York Revolution Trades: Shane Kersten

Trade 113
Pacific gives: Nick Smith + Pick 2
Wellington gives: Thomas Bugg, Pick 5 and Pick 37

Trade 114
Seoul gives: Hayden Ballantyne and Pick 83
Cairo gives: Taylor Hunt and Pick 33

Trade 115
Seoul gives: Chris Dawes and Rhys Stanley
Pacific gives: Sam Darley and Jack Newnes

Trade 116
Moscow gives: Brandon Ellis and Jordan Roughead
Seoul gives: Charlie Dixon, Brad Dick, Josh Thomas and George Burbury

Trade 117
Cape Town gives: Max Gawn + Pick 78
Berlin gives: Stefan Martin

Trade 118
Berlin gives: Pick 45
London gives: Cale Morton

Trade 119
Berlin gives: Daniel Talia
Pacific gives: Pick 37

Trade 120
Cairo gives: Pick 52
Seoul gives: Eric Mackenzie

Trade 121
Mexcio City gives: Mark LeCras and Pick 46
Seoul gives: Paul Duffield and picks 33 and 36

Trade 122
Cape Town give: Picks 15, 17 and Todd Elton
Cape Town receives: Pick 27, Nathan Bock and Lee Spurr

New York give: Jake Melksham and Jarryd Blair
New York receive: Picks 15, 26, Sam Fisher and Todd Elton

New Delhi give: Picks 26, 27, Sam Fisher, Nathan Bock and Lee Spurr
New Delhi receive: Pick 17, Jake Melksham and Jarryd Blair

Trade 123
Moscow give: Bernie Vince and Dayne Beams
Cairo gives: Pick 24, Leigh Adams and Callan Ward

Trade 124
Moscow Trades: Pick 24
Dublin Trades: Preseason Draft Pick 1

Trade 125
Cairo Trades: Ben Jacobs, Ryan Bastinac, Kyal Horsley, Cory Dell'Olio
New Delhi Trades: Pick 18, Josh Gibson, Clinton Young, Orren Stephenson

Trade 126
Mexico City trades: Brock McLean, Chris Knights
Cairo Trades: Pick 18, Jed Adcock, Bernie Vince

Trade 127
Berlin trades: Michael Evans + Pick 50
Cairo Trades: Jamie Cripps + Pick 63

Trade 128
Mexico City trades: Daniel Cross and Sam Gilbert
Buenos Aires trades: Shannon Hurn

Trade 129
Toronto trades: Pick 44, David Hale, Richard Douglas
Cairo trades: Pick 50, Brock McLean, Clinton Young

Trade 130
Cairo trades: Jonathon Griffin
PNL trades: Rohan Bail, Chris Newman

[CrowsFan]

I remember last time we had to include reasons why were doing the trade to let the voters know why you thought it was fair for your team. Will we still have to do that?

[My Chumps]

I remember last time we had to include reasons why were doing the trade to let the voters know why you thought it was fair for your team. Will we still have to do that?

I think we should... Just because it's interesting  :P

[Maca24]

Agree. Makes it easier to vote through trades as well.

[MajorLazer]

Os, I may be wrong, but I was sure I had pick 5 in the draft. I counted in reverse order (yes I can count) and am fairly sure I was the fifth team.

Happy to be proven wrong, well not really, but just want to make sure this is cleared up. :)

[Boomz]

I thought I had 6 :-X

[CrowsFan]

Clarkson and Neeld can pull out of the trade anytime before Saturday if they receive a better offer.

Not a fan of this to be honest. Once a trade has been announced someone can look at it and go "Oh I want that player instead so even though they have agreed a deal with someone else I am going to try and hijack it." Which is exactly what Fark did in the Euros trading before the season. Someone would announce a trade and Fark would say "no don't trade with them I can offer you better." EVERY SINGLE TIME!

Fair enough voting that you don't think a trade is fair, but trying to take that player for yourself is not right. You say you want it to be as similar to the AFL as possible, and obviously they don't have the voting by the other coaches, but once a trade has been announced in the AFL another team can't come in and try and change the trade.

[Holz]

Clarkson and Neeld can pull out of the trade anytime before Saturday if they receive a better offer.

Not a fan of this to be honest. Once a trade has been announced someone can look at it and go "Oh I want that player instead so even though they have agreed a deal with someone else I am going to try and hijack it." Which is exactly what Fark did in the Euros trading before the season. Someone would announce a trade and Fark would say "no don't trade with them I can offer you better." EVERY SINGLE TIME!

Fair enough voting that you don't think a trade is fair, but trying to take that player for yourself is not right. You say you want it to be as similar to the AFL as possible, and obviously they don't have the voting by the other coaches, but once a trade has been announced in the AFL another team can't come in and try and change the trade.

After with this 100% I can see this leading to poaching. I'm happy for deals not to be locked in till voting occurs but a deal should only stop if the trade is deemed unfair in my opinion. As CF said as soon as a deal cones through people will try and undermine it to try andget a deal for themselves.

Something I would also like yo see is no comenting on trades till both people have agreed

[AFEV]

In a massive 3-way deal struck just 3 hours after the trade window opened:

New York Gives:

National draft picks 2, 21, 39, 57 as well as Nick O'Brien and Alex Fasolo

New York Receives

National draft pick 80, Travis Cloke, Trent Mckenzie and Ayce Cordy

Reasoning

We were in dire need of a forward (as a lot of the teams in WXV are) and Travis Cloke fit the bill, despite question marks over where he'll be next year and whether he can get back to '11 form - We believe he's what we've been looking for. Additionally it is guaranteed he will remain selectable as a forward his entire career.

We needed a succession plan for our current ruck duo in Cox and Pyke. Both of them are 28 and are beginning to near the end of their careers. Ayce is 22 and has shown a lot of promise to date, after he puts on some more weight we are confident he will be able to duel with the best.

Trent Mckenzie also gives us a valuable boost in the midfield, and gives us wiggle room to offer some other players as trade bait this off-season.


(Above) Travis Cloke shows his elation upon hearing about moving to NY (btw why do italics show as bold?)

[Boomz]

In a massiv 3 way deal struck just 3 hours after the trade window opened:

New York Gives:

National draft picks 2, 21, 39, 57 as well as Nick O'Brien and Alex Fasolo

New York Receives

National draft pick 80, Travis Cloke, Trent Mckenzie and Ayce Cordy

Reasoining

We were in dire need of a forward (as a lot of the teams in WXV are) and Travis Cloke fit the bill, despite question marks over where he'll be next year and whether he can get back to '11 form - We believe he's what we've been looking for. Additionally it is guaranteed he will remain selectable as a forward his entire career.

Additionally, we needed a succession plan for our current ruck duo in Cox and Pyke. Both of them are 28 and are beginning to near the end of their careers. Ayce is 22 and has shown a lot of promise to date, after he puts on some more weight we are confident he will be able to duel with the best.

Trent Mckenzie also gives us a valuable boost in the midfield, and gives us wiggle room to offer some other players as trade bait this off-season.

CONFIRMED

Tokyo Gives: Mckenzie, Blease, Pick 6, Cloke, Cordy
Tokyo Recieves: Judd, Pick 21, Suban, Townsend, Fasolo, Nick O'Brien

Reasoning:

We are aiming for top 4 next season and believe we needed another premium mid and Judd fits the bill. While we didn't really want to lose Mckenzie or pick 6 it was a sacrifice we were willing to make as we also gained 2 solid defenders who will help fix our weak defence in Townsend & Suban. Fasolo will replace Cloke in the forward line while Nick O'Brien will be good back up and may even replace another player likely to be traded who I won't mention just yet. Blease while he has potential isn't in our best side and quite a way back in the pecking order so he was happy to go to a new club. Cordy is a solid young ruckman and battled valiantly for the Samurai this year in place of the injured Leuenberger but we believe we can replace him fairly easily in the draft or via trade.

Also I apologise to all those interested in Cloke. If you feel you can offer a substantially better deal then you can still offer and I will consider before Saturday but it is unlikely.

[c4v3m4n]

In a massiv 3 way deal struck just 3 hours after the trade window opened:

New York Gives:

National draft picks 2, 21, 39, 57 as well as Nick O'Brien and Alex Fasolo

New York Receives

National draft pick 80, Travis Cloke, Trent Mckenzie and Ayce Cordy

Reasoining

We were in dire need of a forward (as a lot of the teams in WXV are) and Travis Cloke fit the bill, despite question marks over where he'll be next year and whether he can get back to '11 form - We believe he's what we've been looking for. Additionally it is guaranteed he will remain selectable as a forward his entire career.

Additionally, we needed a succession plan for our current ruck duo in Cox and Pyke. Both of them are 28 and are beginning to near the end of their careers. Ayce is 22 and has shown a lot of promise to date, after he puts on some more weight we are confident he will be able to duel with the best.

Trent Mckenzie also gives us a valuable boost in the midfield, and gives us wiggle room to offer some other players as trade bait this off-season.

CONFIRMED

Tokyo Gives: Mckenzie, Blease, Pick 6, Cloke, Cordy
Tokyo Recieves: Judd, Pick 21, Suban, Townsend, Fasolo, Nick O'Brien

Reasoning:

We are aiming for top 4 next season and believe we needed another premium mid and Judd fits the bill. While we didn't really want to lose Mckenzie or pick 6 it was a sacrifice we were willing to make as we also gained 2 solid defenders who will help fix our weak defence in Townsend & Suban. Fasolo will replace Cloke in the forward line while Nick O'Brien will be good back up and may even replace another player likely to be traded who I won't mention just yet. Blease while he has potential isn't in our best side and quite a way back in the pecking order so he was happy to go to a new club. Cordy is a solid young ruckman and battled valiantly for the Samurai this year in place of the injured Leuenberger but we believe we can replace him fairly easily in the draft or via trade.

Also I apologise to all those interested in Cloke. If you feel you can offer a substantially better deal then you can still offer and I will consider before Saturday but it is unlikely.

CONFIRMED

Just to clarify, the full three way trade is as follows:

Tokyo Samurai gives: Sam Blease, Travis Cloke, Trent McKenzie, Ayce Cody and ND pick 6.
Tokyo Samurai gets: Chris Judd, Alex Fasolo, Nick Suban, Jacob Townsend, Nicholas O'Brien and ND pick 21.

New York Eagles gives: Alex Fasolo, Nicholas O'Brien and ND picks 2, 21, 39 and 57.
New York Eagles recieves: Travis Cloke, Trent McKenzie, Ayce Cordy and ND pick 80.

Pacific Islanders give: Chris Judd, Nick Suban, Jacob Townsend and ND pick 80.
Pacific Islanders receive: Sam Blease and ND picks 2, 6, 39 and 57.

Our Reasoning

The Pacific Islanders have always maintained that we intend on heading in a more youth-orientated direction and getting two of the top 10 draft picks is a great result for the future of the club and something we were definitely after. We are still looking for young developing talent but in the meantime, Sam Blease fits that bill nicely after some great performances in recent weeks and we have no doubt that he'll be a fantastic midfielder in years to come and a great addition to the Islanders.

A great win for all clubs involved. Sad to see captain Judd go though. :-\

[ossie85]

Yeah, reasoning does make it more interested, happy with that.

I think you've convinced me CF, happy to abolish the 'poaching' rule... what do others think?

And wow, big trade guys!

[Boomz]

Yeah, reasoning does make it more interested, happy with that.

I think you've convinced me CF, happy to abolish the 'poaching' rule... what do others think?

And wow, big trade guys!

Ossie can you confirm about the draft order?  :-X (See the above posts from ML & me)

[ossie85]

Yeah, sorry guys, screwed up the order was looking at a different ladder lol.

Should be fixed now

[Boomz]

and yeah I agree I'm not really a big fan of the poaching rule... I still say the trade should be able to be cancelled if both coaches agree to it though before the Saturday.