Double Trade Coming My Way

[Locinator]

I am gonna cop a donut this week if I do not trade. So here is what I have come up with

Current Side

Defenders
Brendan Goddard, Brett Deledio, Greg Broughton, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Tomas Bugg, Jack Hombsch
Heath Shaw, Brandon Ellis

Midfielders
Tom Rockliff, Joel Selwood, Dylan Shiel, James Magner, James McDonald, Stephen Coniglio
Dayne Zorko, Gary Ablett

Rucks
Shane Mumford, Jonathon Giles
Orren Stephenson, Jarred Redden

Forwards
Lance Franklin, Nathan Fyfe, Cyril Rioli, Dustin Martin, Steele Sidebottom, Patrick Dangerfield, Devon Smith
Adam Kennedy, Aaron Hall


Potential Side


Defenders
Brendan Goddard, Brett Deledio, Greg Broughton, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Tomas Bugg, Jack Hombsch
Heath Shaw, Brandon Ellis

Midfielders
Tom Rockliff, Joel Selwood, Dylan Shiel, James Magner, James McDonald, Stephen Coniglio
Dayne Zorko, Gary Ablett

Rucks
NIC NAITANUI Jonathon Giles
Orren Stephenson, Shane Mumford

Forwards
Lance Franklin, Cyril Rioli, Dustin Martin, Steele Sidebottom, Patrick Dangerfield, Devon Smith, ADAM TRELOAR
Adam Kennedy, Aaron Hall

Trades Are:

Nathan Fyfe - Adam Treloar
Jarrad Redden - Nic Naitanui

Reasoning

Fyfe-Treloar- Fyfe is definitely going to slump in value and Trealoar looks to average 70+. I had Treloar all pre-season until the NAB started and I rate him highly. The plan is if Fyfe doesn't re injure himself I will pounce on him before the byes and have the same bye structure coming into the byes.

Redden- Naitanui- Nic Nat has always been on my radar. The off putting part for me was his consistency and this year he has convinced me he will be consistent with scores of 105, 108, 101 and 102. Redden is on the outer over Big O because his JS is bad now with Lobbe coming back soon and Renouf back last week.

Your opinion Guys and Girls 

[GoldDigger]

Do Mummy --> NicNat instead - Mummy's out for ages ...

I'd keep Fyfe now he's named. Do in someone else if you think you must have Treloar.

[Ringo]

I would do Mummy to Nat as well and maybe Hall who is not named to Treloar if you want him.

[mpollock]

Fyfe named and you didn't trade him last week so may as well keep him.
Mummy to Ryder/Kruizer is my suggestion.
Then easy to sideways trade to Treloar if you feel the need ... i wouldn't bother personally.

[bradw]

nicnat and griffin share the bye in rd11. I have mummy too and thinking that trading in nicnat may cause a perilous situation...

[bradw]

I meant Nicnat and Giles....oops

[Ringo]

Depends who your other 2 rucks are and if they are playing. Also come byes Giles may be slackening off and you may wish to upgrade him as well. With Reddan and Stephenson not getting game time either and they are probably your bench as well looking at what options there are with getting in R/F DPP  Roughy, Ryder and then say Rowe or Pattinson to open the link similar to how most of us used Tippet last year.