rate for a rate

[fattony]

help out a ff tragic. rate and i'll rate you back

Clissold's Cainers
Remaining Cap: $53,300

DEF: B Goddard, B Deledio, G Broughton, D Heppell, P Hanley, R Hargrave, B Ellis (S Darley, S Morris)

MID: G Ablett, J Selwood, S Thompson, L Hayes, J Caddy, D Shiel (S Clifton, J Magner)

RUCK: B McEvoy, J Giles (J Redden, O Stephenson)

FWD: N Fyfe, M Robinson, D Martin, S Sidebottom, P Dangerfield, J Porplyzia, A Kennedy (S Kerridge, A Hall)

[its me lads]

DEF: i dont think heppel is the best option not a high roof. not keen on hanley eaither

MId: lenny hayes good risk.

RUCK: not bad wouldve went mummy over mcevoy

FWD:good apart from mitchy robbo better options out there

overall 8/10 not too shabby

rate mine please.

Remaining Cap: $22,500

DEF: H Scotland, B Goddard, B Deledio, G Broughton, P Duffield, R Hargrave, B Ellis, T Bugg, S Darley

MID: S Pendlebury, G Ablett, J Watson, N van Berlo, C Smith, J Magner, A Miles, J McDonald

RUCK: S Mumford, J Giles, J Redden, O Stephenson

FWD: L Franklin, N Fyfe, T Cloke, D Martin, P Dangerfield, J Porplyzia, D Pfeiffer, A Hall, T Couch

[yorgis]

hayes is NOT injury prone, he's missed 8 games from 2007, [4 years]  yyou could say that at 32 years of age he may find

it hard to get back to his best from a knee, but he's definately not injury prone

[Chopps]

hayes is NOT injury prone, he's missed 8 games from 2007, [4 years]  yyou could say that at 32 years of age he may find

it hard to get back to his best from a knee, but he's definately not injury prone

+1 , come back from an acl at that age is going to be hard

[Zombie2.5]

Yeah Lenny IS NOT injury prone, before his BAD LUCK knee injury im pretty sure he played most games.
But he is getting old and coming bak from injury and there are better options. How bout Jack steven whos around same price lenny, up and rising also a good POD(point of difference) or unique.

Anyways

Defenders: Solid but id rather get waters over hanley (although he is injury prone) and just a note that hargrave is quite old now.
I reckon Beau waters of  will be the 2010 Beau waters of 2012 8) :P
Midfielders: Good, not so sure bout lenny as i said above), possibly downgrade caddy and upg lenny.
Rucks: I went with McEvoy over Mumford too, i like him as only ruckman, although seaby doesnt really count as second ruck to mummy.
Forwards: I like but i wouldnt have porpz AND danger, maybe one down to rook and other to Gray/premium
Overall solid team P hanley and some midpricers could be good PODs and good luck for season 2012!!
7/10

Please rate mine, everyone else feel free to rate too, greatly appreciated.

BACKS: B.Goddard, H.Shaw, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, B.Waters, B.Ellis, T.Bugg (S.Darley, S.Morris)
MIDS: S.Pendlebury, M.Boyd, G.Ablett, J.Redden, S.Coniglion, A.Kennedy (C.Smith, J.Magner)
RUCKS: B.McEvoy, J.Giles (J.Redden, O.Stephensen)
FORWARDS: L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, D.Martin, S.Sidebottom, R.Gray, D.Smith, B.Smedts (A.Hall, T.Dickson)

Thanks please rate /10 and give your opinions.

[fattony]

Remaining Cap: $22,500

DEF: H Scotland, B Goddard, B Deledio, G Broughton, P Duffield, R Hargrave, B Ellis, T Bugg, S Darley

MID: S Pendlebury, G Ablett, J Watson, N van Berlo, C Smith, J Magner, A Miles, J McDonald

RUCK: S Mumford, J Giles, J Redden, O Stephenson

FWD: L Franklin, N Fyfe, T Cloke, D Martin, P Dangerfield, J Porplyzia, D Pfeiffer, A Hall, T Couch

looking pretty solid mate, Watson and van Berlo are good POD's in the mids and Cloke looks the goods again this season. Interesting that you've gone for both broughton and duffield in def. also, you're going to have to get rid of couch because he wasn't elevated from the rookie list.

8/10

BACKS: B.Goddard, H.Shaw, B.Deledio, G.Broughton, B.Waters, B.Ellis, T.Bugg (S.Darley, S.Morris)
MIDS: S.Pendlebury, M.Boyd, G.Ablett, J.Redden, S.Coniglion, A.Kennedy (C.Smith, J.Magner)
RUCKS: B.McEvoy, J.Giles (J.Redden, O.Stephensen)
FORWARDS: L.Franklin, M.Pavlich, D.Martin, S.Sidebottom, R.Gray, D.Smith, B.Smedts (A.Hall, T.Dickson)

Thanks please rate /10 and give your opinions.

Good setup in defence, although i cringe every time i see h shaw in a team ;)
Boyd and Redden are both good choices in the midfield
Can't say anything bad about your rucks as they're a carbon copy of mine
I'd probably look for someone other than smedts at F7, he hasnt really shown much this preseason and you have no DPP link in defence

overall, 7.5/10

[essendon2]

I gave it a 9/10,
Caddy should average 85
Hanley and Heppell between 85-90
Hayes 95-105
and Dangerfield 85-90