As long as tbey are all picked i think im done. very happy :-)

[cortez]

before you rate please read this. im not concerned about byes so please dont bring that subject into your rating and also please no sheep like quotes because i have heard it all before. your honest opinion pkease. other than that let me have it :-)

DEF: B. Goddard, B. Deledio, H. Shaw, G. Birchall, G. Broughton, B. Ellis, S. Morris (B. Smedts, T. Bugg)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, D. Swan, J. Selwood, S. Coniglio, T. Ledger, D. Shiel (J. McDonald, J. Magner)
RUC: S. Mumford, J. Giles (J. Redden, O. Stephenson)
FWD: L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, P. Chapman, D. Martin, T. Cloke, D. Smith, D. Pfeiffer (A. Kennedy, T. Dickson)
CASH LEFT: $12,200

[cortez]

is there something wrong with my team that you cant rate it?

[DCAK]

Hi Cortez, I like your team mate and, like you was impressed with Ledger on the weekend, but will he get a run?

Also, it's just my opinion, but given you're running the 1 prem ruck theory I'd expect more depth in your mids than Coniglio @ M4.

8/10

[cortez]

Hi Cortez, I like your team mate and, like you was impressed with Ledger on the weekend, but will he get a run?

Also, it's just my opinion, but given you're running the 1 prem ruck theory I'd expect more depth in your mids than Coniglio @ M4.

8/10

Yea i reckon he will get a run if not ill prob put claye smith in. and with coniglio as 4th mid. i have 14 prems and have concentrated more on stocking backs as you can see with broughton as b5 and cloke as f5. i have gone this way due to the scoring potential of the rookie mids and with 3 super prems in gaz, swan and jelwood i think i still have enough scoring power. am i on the right track with that logic?

[tor01doc]

Ey corteth,

Comethta?

Me bueno.

Love your team.

5 premiums down back. Leaves room for who? Newman, Bock, Scotland or Suckling. No wonder Coniglio is @ M4.

3 mid guns - all mighty fine.

Cox later - you shrewd money saving dude.

T Clunk @ F5 though. Why? Won't he be gloveless? Means only 2 of Goodes, SJ, Rioli, Pav,  Danger!! or Roughead to fit in.

Nice team with a few bye (sorry  :-[) issues the only reason you're getting 9.2/10 and that's assuming you get your rookies right.

14 premiums is very handy.

BTW is rioligun your mate?

[DCAK]

I can't answer that mate, it's in the lap of the SC gods!

[cortez]

Thanks tor01doc,  and a strange feeling about cloke. he is 25 just coming into his prime. reckon he will def avg 100+ hopefully 110. is a bit of a unique option you know cant have all the guns even though it would be great. thanks for your opinion i respect it . and na he isnt my mate. seems like a White Goodman from his rate my coach thread! why you ask?

[tor01doc]

Thought you were chiming in giving the guy an eyeful which is good karma.

See you in the finals.  ;D

[cortez]

i gave him a bit lol. see you then.

[MartyNadort]

Hey bud,

BACKS = Possibly to many Premiums (5) in the backs leaving your mids weak. 2 Tigs & GWS rookies could leave you stranded in bye.
MIDS = lacking a premium in M4. Good rookies
RUCKS = Going for the rookie ruck line-up could be risky??
FORWARDS = Good forwards, and good rookies!

Rate 8/10

[Degsman]

I like it!!!

9/10 for me

I like the fact you have 14 premiums!!