hopefully im done before nab. thoughts?

Started by ando_10, February 10, 2012, 12:36:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

Salary cap left: $17,400.

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Greg Broughton, Jack Grimes, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Brandon Ellis
Tomas Bugg, Billie Smedts

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Marc Murphy, Michael Barlow, Dylan Shiel, Dayne Zorko
Luke Brown, James McDonald

Ben McEvoy, Hamish McIntosh
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Matthew Pavlich, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Darren Pfeiffer, Adam Treloar
Tommy Walsh, Sam Kerridge

Free Kick

Our mids are identical ando.. Good choices 8)

Grimes and lake both have thier risks.. The question you have to ask is do you choose both??

Almost choose McEvoy and he should do well, but I went with Mumford as he can monster most other ruckmen and produce very high scores. Also went Mcintosh to save some cash but hoping he can be up around the 90 to 110 considtently. Time will tell.

Solid fwds with Brown too cheap to pass up.

Rookies (pending NAB cup performances)

Good luck 8)

Wild Thing

Interesting side ando.  You will be realtively unique I would think with the mid pricers being in (Brown, Grimes, Lake, Barlow, Zaharakis, McIntosh) so it could really pay off.  I like the fact you haven't just gone with something different.  I have some concerns on Lake (injury/form/confidence), Grimes (injury), Barlow (hard tags), McIntosh (TOG), Brown (Key forward in an ordinary side) but they may all be proven wrong, and for your sake, I hope they are.

ando_10

thanks guys ill work out the lake/grimes situation i really wanna keep grimes in there and who knows what lakes capable of this year so we will have to see :)

DC2011

backs: look very solid, only the one rookie player on the field which is a good sign.

mids: looks good, a main set up that i see a lot, 3 prems and barlow with 4 rookies, shiel should be a high scoring player i reckon.

rucks: bit different but could pay off, mcevoy should keep up his scoring from 2011 but not too sold on mcintosh as goldstein will take number 1 ruck role and petrie in the forward.

forwards: like the look of your forwards, very very solid. overall a pretty good team i reckon, looks good, well done mate, 8.5/10

ando_10

Quote from: DC2011 on February 10, 2012, 05:52:07 PM
backs: look very solid, only the one rookie player on the field which is a good sign.

mids: looks good, a main set up that i see a lot, 3 prems and barlow with 4 rookies, shiel should be a high scoring player i reckon.

rucks: bit different but could pay off, mcevoy should keep up his scoring from 2011 but not too sold on mcintosh as goldstein will take number 1 ruck role and petrie in the forward.

forwards: like the look of your forwards, very very solid. overall a pretty good team i reckon, looks good, well done mate, 8.5/10

yeah i also have my doubts about Hmac so hes skating on thin ice in my side atm minute he has to have good NAB :)

oldshepp

I agree with HMac. Roos are being a bit greedy hanging on to him.  I don't believe there is a permanent spot for him in their side, let alone any guarantee of alot of game time