why no love for jimmy?

Started by corzer03, February 02, 2012, 01:07:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

corzer03

everyone keeps talking about selwood, johnson and chappy but why not bartel? avg. 101 last year and was tearing i up last year until he got knocked out and is 60k cheaper than selwood

ando_10

can really stink it up though. like sub par 70s etc.

corzer03

#2
Quote from: ando_10 on February 02, 2012, 01:08:33 PM
can really stink it up though. like sub par 70s etc.
barely though, and i was looking at him instead of selwood and then upgrade dangerfield to franklin

upthemaidens

Quote from: corzer03 on February 02, 2012, 01:07:05 PM
everyone keeps talking about selwood, johnson and chappy but why not bartel? avg. 101 last year and was tearing i up last year until he got knocked out and is 60k cheaper than selwood
u answered your own question,,,,, avg.101,,,    20 less than an ultra premo

jfitty

I reckon there are better options in that price range, guys like Redden, Gibbs and Cotchin could be better picks. Although having said that it's hard to ignore the fact that Jimmy has had seasons averaging 115 and 125 in the past!

Dudge

Theres plenty of love for Jimmy from me, it's just a matter of structure and price. All that being said, i still think he will score very well

cortez

jimmy bartel superstar he's won more premierships than stkilda.

Hes loved so much he has a chant going for him!!!

thatguy

the fact he is used in different positions now affects his output. he is the junk time specialist... i lost count on how many times he was looking at poor scores until a 4th quarter blitz!

Capper

i think that fact that he will be spending more time up front like last year has warned people off

enzedder

Quote from: cortez on February 02, 2012, 03:19:48 PM
jimmy bartel superstar he's won more premierships than stkilda.
So have probably 1000s of players....so what.
Selwood is the one you want...Bartel is $2 shop in comparison.

upthemaidens

hes also sharing the rd.12 bye with the cream of the crop midfielders,,  which would be another turn off.
  will be unique thats for sure

cortez

3 premierships brownlow and norm smith. think thats definately a superstar...

corzer03

#12
Quote from: Dudge on February 02, 2012, 03:13:33 PM
Theres plenty of love for Jimmy from me, it's just a matter of structure and price. All that being said, i still think he will score very well
would he fit in the structure i have which is pendles murphy bartel cotchin clay smith dylan shiel zorko and sexton?

charliesheen

role change.  you don't know which bartel you are gonna get.


corzer03

who would be a better option in that price range then??