Over from the Dark Side

Started by mattgopies, January 15, 2012, 02:38:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mattgopies

Boomshackalaka Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by mattgopies. Salary cap left: $1,500.

Hi Guys, Been doing DT for a while but this is my first real crack at SC. Any advice would be great

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Greg Broughton, Jack Grimes, Nathan Grima, Marty Clarke, Adam Tomlinson
Tim Golds, Steven Morris

Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett jnr, Trent Cotchin, Michael Barlow, Sam Docherty, Adam Treloar
Luke Brown, James McDonald

Matthew Leuenberger, Ben McEvoy
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Nick Riewoldt, Steele Sidebottom, Jonathan Brown, Stephen Clifton, Darren Pfeiffer
Billie Smedts, Dayne Zorko

charliesheen

I would only take one of Grimes or Grima for team balance.  Also gives you a backup option, if you need to cut your losses.

Would use those funds probably to upgrade Cotchin & one of zaha or sidebottom.  I personally feel you need at least 3 premium mids you know will be in the top 7 for the year.

Team looks pretty solid though.

lozza63

Matt i reckon Charlie's advice is on the money - i reckon you need a j.Selwood in those mids - Grima is unlikely to score as well as Grimes, then again i had Jack lst year and couldnt stand the thought of trding him out with an lti around mid year.

Purple 77

Yeah, probably should only take EITHER grimes or grima, if you wanted you could downgrade one to say, b.ellis, and upgrade the other to another premium like shaw?

The ruck is the same as mine (have updated from posted team), so i can't fault it  ;D

Cotchin is interesting......... but i dont see why he wont work, improving all the time in an improving team. Docherty is in brisbanes rehab group, so maybe he isn't a good idea yet, definately for the future. I will be picking him if he makes and does well in the nab cup. you could replace him for someone like tom mitchell, young sydney gun set to go well.

By the way, the forum has clifton listed as a forward but in fact he is a midfielder

Nice team as well

mattgopies

Thanks for feedback guys

Will take on feedback regards to grimes and grima.

Depending on NAB cup but Im pretty keen on Cotchin at the minute.  Love the way he goes about it, comes across very well and seems the ultra professional.

Colliwobblers

man great side, grima is tearing up pre-season and grimes is a proven GUN if he stays fir, llok closely at nab cup to see how all the guys are going, but i am loving your team it is a smoker!!!!

damn good job imo

mattgopies

Thanks wobbler!

Keen to get Franklin in but not sure how yet!