Main Menu

OP 007

Started by Torress, January 04, 2012, 03:32:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Torress

this is team atm 4/1/2012

help me out and give some opinions, i think if anything i'd drop hayes to make room elswhere. do want pendles but this team aint got him atm

BACKS -  GOD, lids, johncock, bock, grima, geary, marty clarke      emg - sierakowski, morris

MIDS - GAJ (C) , swan, jelwood, hayes, koby stevens, tom mitchell      emg - zorko, shiel

RUCKS - Mummy, Hmac     emg - giles, stephenson

FORWARDS - buddy, martin, dangerfield, JB, porpz, jarred moore, saad     emg - clifton, walsh

$32,900 remaining

i like danger if he gets majority of time playing on the ball if not he'll be axed.
johncock apparently is having a good preseason
tempted to drop hayes for a rookie and upgrade porpz and moore

Patrician

Looks pretty good.

Only two comments. Bock is suspended for two matches, not much of an issue if you're going for league but might want to consider if you're going for overall.

And Hmac as R2 I think might be risky. Could pay off but I would personally get another leading Ruck, if you can find the cash.

Torress

cheers mate bock is gone!
mate Hmac is only there as a mid pricer will be looking to upgrade if i start him

Ringo

Would prefer Trent West to H Mac as second ruck.  H mac will probably play second fiddle to Goldie whereas West will be No 1 Ruck at Geelong to start with.  Very little Difference in price.

Watch some of these players pre season to how they are coming back from injury Grima, Geary, Hayes, Brown, Moore and Porplyza.  Also observe how Danger is being used. 

lozza63

Hey Torress - 4 forrwards which are rather risky imo

The likes of Moore, Danger dont enthuse as serious contenders for top 10 fwd. Moore had a very disappointing 2011 and Danger just doesnt seem to have the tank to run in the midfield all day yet - maybe he'll be fine this year but for mine a combo of those two - dont inspire confidence.

Hmac is way too contentoius a choice - totally agree with Ringo there, West would be better choice as the clear number one for his club. Also that achilles problem just makes him a no-no.

Hayes - 32 year old bloke returning from injury - too risky even at 420k odd.

Geary - that guy will be lucky to play 12 games let alone be fantasy relevant imo - look elsewhere.