Libba or Curnow?

[Just Clancy]

I've made up my mind that i'm trading Atley for one of these two. As far as i'm concerned i'm not wasting a trade. I was going to bring in Curnow but he has Pies this week and Libba got a 118 and is versing Gold Coast this week. I'm basically going to be starting one of these two on the field over Swallow as i reckon they'll both outscore him.

[jfitty]

Libba for me. Dogs seem to rate him quite highly so job security should be pretty good. Carlton still have a few guys to come back so Curnow may make room for them. The thing is that Atley would have better JS then both of them IMO so don't wanna trade him for someone who may get dropped

[Nails]

Why are you looking at who they play next week only?

Surely you're not going to trade them out after rd 3. You have to look who they're playing for the next 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 games i.e. however long you plan to have them...

I'm not sold on getting libba or curnow in though.

[elephants]

curnow. i have boyd an bewick so round 4 will be tough if i get libba

[Just Clancy]

curnow. i have boyd an bewick so round 4 will be tough if i get libba

If i did get Libba i'd be able to field a full midfield but i'd have no cover on the bench come round 4.

[elephants]

Yeah same here JC. My mpp backs would be handy then too if hibberd doesn't play

[BigV]

I need help to decide my trades for round three.

Going Prestia > Tapscott

Then, Smith > Curnow or Libba.

[MissPiesFF]

Libba but doggies  have bye round 4. Post this under DT trades forum you'll get more of  a response  ;)

[Holz]

liba easy over cunrow unless he causes round 4 problems.

[BigV]

Aware of that so I'm going with Curnow.

[Mish]

Aware of that so I'm going with Curnow.

+1

[cortez]

How about you just go with your gut cause either one would be a good pick

[Just Clancy]

Libba but doggies  have bye round 4. Post this under DT trades forum you'll get more of  a response  ;)

It is in DT trades.  :P