Please Rate - Rate for a rate

[hally25547]

Hey guys, my latest team so i was just wondering if you could rate it and give me some feedback - it would be greatly appreciated. I am going for a league win but i would like a respectable overall score so in the top 1000. Cheers Hally  :)

My updated team is;

TEAM NAME: Hall of Fame

DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, B. Deledio, G. Broughton, J. Grimes, A. Otten, J. Toy (N. Duigan, M. Hibberd, P. Puopolo)

MID: D. Swan, M. Boyd, L. Montagna, J. Bartel, D. Heppell, D. Harris (T. Mzungu, I. Smith, S.Atley)

RUC: A. Sandilands, D. Petrie (Z. Smith, M. Bailey)

FWD: P. Chapman, L. Franklin, C. Sylvia, N. Riewoldt, C. Knights, A. Krakouer, D. Prestia (B. Matera, C. Richardson, L. Tapscott)

CASH LEFT: $48,500

Overall pretty happy with it, i would just like some feedback and other peoples thoughts. Cheers Hally

*Due to so many comments about not having Sandilands i have traded him in for Cox and in order to be able to do that i traded D Swallow to S Atley. Thoughts??

[Mooeyj]

great team... no real weaknesses...
but not getting sandi could hurt you

[XxBrayden]

Agree with that call a very good team ith some nice Uniques I agree picking up sandi will help immensely I rate him a must have!!

Could you re rate my team I think u rated the old team :D no longer have carrazzo cheeers mate

[hally25547]

cheers guys - i did have sandi but i heard that he is in doubt for the nab with knee issues and has missed the passed couple of trainings. I also think Cox is good value and as i would have to change my team to afford him i think he is better off as an upgrade target.

[hally25547]

please rate as well as comment, cheers

[TheMantle]

2 gold coast mids will hurt first round? i had the same problem
8 out 10

[luckyanton]

Decent team, gave it a 9/10. Could get a better 4th ruck but that is a very minor issue. Rate mine please :)

[hally25547]

@ The Mantle i have been thinking of not having Swallow but with MPP and his good job security i will have to find a way in round 1 to keep him.

Thanks luckyanton i think i will get Bailey from Hawks and i will rate yours now

[chrisuzz]

Like the MPP use of Heppell who can swap with God, Gibbs and Dlids was originally the sort of structure i was gonna go for. Also Grimes and Broughton good choices.

Strong midfield with plenty of captain choices, and Heppell as said.

Also in ur forward line uve got a couple MPP options which is good.

Only things i dont like are no MPP for Petrie, but thats not vital if u dont want it. But i think u should try and get Sandi in there some how, or swap Cox with Ryder.

[hally25547]

i would like to get sandi in there but in previous comment above i have highlighted the reasons i dont have. Paddy Ryder is definitely an option.

Who does everyone think is the better option
cox or ryder

[chrisuzz]

well Ryder is an upcoming star, already pretty good i must say and Cox is coming towards the end of his career, with NicNat starting to steal the spotlight

[Jimbo_11]

great team

dont see any real problems at all,
except cox instead of sandi is a really ballsy move, hope it pays off, but personally i'd pick sandi

9/10

[hally25547]

thanks Jimbo

[Babylove]

I think it's a fairly solid team as well.  I'd be wary of having so many Suns in your team with the byes but if you think you can cover them they should be solid cash earners for you.  I also agree about swapping Cox for Sandi, Sandi should be a solid earner for you especially with Freo on the rise.

[hawksrule]

pretty solid team i rated 8.5 only things i would think about changing is the lack of sandy and maybe looking at replacements for bartel or chapman. but then again i think thats more personal pref than anything else. they are both awesome players.

my team is pretty similar to yours please rate :)
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,25713.0.html