Rate This!

[Knowall]

Im really surprised how much money i had left over! 370,900 :o
DEF:
Gibbs
Delidio
Broughton
Hurn
Grimes
Heppell
Jacobs
(Toy, Puopolo, Coad)
MID:
Goddard
Pendles
Vince (If hes fit)
Shuey (almost as cheap as rookie but will average 10+ pts more)
Swallow
Polec
(Blease, Hibberd/Iles, Mzungu)
Ruck:
Sandi
Petrie (really iffy about him, I can afford to upgrade)
(Smith, McDonald)
FWD:
Riewoldt
Franklin
Pavlich
Sylvia
Dangerfield (My little risk im willing to take im expecting breakout)
Knights
Prestia
(Smith, Richardson, Tapscott) I might chuck Tapscott in their

So as u can see i can either upgrade Petrie or i couldup grade maybe polec and get another decent mid.
Like i have done with ur teams could u please rate and comment thanks :)

[BoredSaint]

you can afford to upgrade vince..

[Knowall]

you can afford to upgrade vince..

nah i will keep Vince unless he doesnt play nab cup or looks really shaky.

I was considerin upgrading Polec to Anthony and Petrie to Clark

[BoredSaint]

whats the price of shuey?

[Knowall]

whats the price of shuey?

I really rate him as a bargain hell play every game and scores pretty well.  Shuey 224k and Polec is worth 194 or something seems worth it to me.

[BoredSaint]

why is he that cheap?

[tferrier18]

you have gibbs twice

[Knowall]

you have gibbs twice

sorry its grimes

[HillHero13]

Backline: Good, nothing wrong.. only risk is 2 rookies, but you see most teams like that..

Mids: good, Polec i'm not too sure on because i haven't really heard anything on him.. Shuey and Vince are risky but could pay off..

Rucks: Standard

Fowards; Dangerfield AND knights.. is a no, but other than that it's good.


8.5/10

[Knowall]

Backline: Good, nothing wrong.. only risk is 2 rookies, but you see most teams like that..

Mids: good, Polec i'm not too sure on because i haven't really heard anything on him.. Shuey and Vince are risky but could pay off..

Rucks: Standard

Fowards; Dangerfield AND knights.. is a no, but other than that it's good.


8.5/10

THanks HH for the comments, most teams have Otten in their team and for me hes just as risky as a good rookie
Thinking of maybe swapping knights for petrie and  then getting a better ruckman any suggestions?
Im happy with shuey and vince.
Yea Polec will be just as good as gaff imo, but it looks like the extra 30k to get shuey is worth it.

[4820]

Re paying the favour "Knowall"
Backs - Sam Isles is listed as a Mid in the 2011 Prospectus, put Isles in the place of Blease (mid) ? Personally rather have Heppell on the bench (not sure what Hirdy has got in mind for him) for his MPP.
I have picked Grimes but he is a concern re injuries.
Richardson is listed as a fwd in the prospectus.
I'd prefer to see Goddard in the back line.
Mid - Vince "No" wouldn't touch him.
Blease ????? not sure
Shuey may end up being a reallly smart pick, I have considered him (only briefly I must admit).
I went Conca over Polec, but I really like Polac so that may change. Why did you go Polec over Conca?
Ruck - Just tonight took Petrie out of my side, who knows with him. 
Fwd -   I went Goodes over Pav because he was cheaper and Pav last year was starting to have some injuries issues. Had Danger last year never again (to hard at the ball for his own good).

Hooper ???? not sure.
IMO probably needs 1 or 2 more Prem in there. No Swan (big call)...
Good luck...

[Knowall]

Thanks for the feedback im not getting much love over here  :-[
Polec has played SANFL for one or two years- Hes ready
Heppell will play Hird just playing around keeping the kid on his feet.
I love Grimes as a player wanted him in their could prove to be a great scorer.
Blease will play, has had injury issues is the reason why he hasnt allready
Pav only had small injuries hed bne over those id imagine
Hooper im not sure either  :P
Swan=Overpriced and overrated i allready have Goddard and Pendles

Ive made some changes would really like suggestions regarding spare cash!!
Ive changed rookies to fit position changes btw

[4820]

Coad is a good pick i reckon. Coad will play. I would probably start Coad in the place of Heppell and replace Hibberd with Heppell (not sure if Hibberd will play a heap).  Backs are o.k. 2 GC players on the bench not ideal, but you could get away with it, provided Heppell, Jacobs & Puopolo play rnd 1.
The mids need another premium or 2 in there imo. The team overall could do with a couple more prem.
If your iffy on Petrie upgrade him to Jolly or someone ?
Fwds are good (im not keen on danger). I assume I. Smith (Haw) on the bench ? Could consider Darling, Matera (cheaper options) or Krakour IMO. 2 Haw players in fwd line not ideal (re the bye) but again could get away with it as I. Smith MPP. Same with 2 Adel players in fwd line. 
Looks like you have 9 prem, most teams have aroung 12. 
All just my opinion.

[Knowall]

Yea the rookies were done pretty quickly.
Im not sure where u got 9 from.  5 in def + 2 (possibly 3 for Vince) +Sandi+ 4 in fwd line.  So thats 12 potentially 13 plus another when i use the spare coin

[Maca24]

Im really surprised how much money i had left over! 370,900 :o
DEF:
Gibbs
Delidio
Broughton
Hurn
Grimes
Heppell
Jacobs
(Toy, Puopolo, Coad)
MID:
Goddard
Pendles
Vince (If hes fit)
Shuey (almost as cheap as rookie but will average 10+ pts more)
Swallow
Polec
(Blease, Hibberd/Iles, Mzungu)
Ruck:
Sandi
Petrie (really iffy about him, I can afford to upgrade)
(Smith, McDonald)
FWD:
Riewoldt
Franklin
Pavlich
Sylvia
Dangerfield (My little risk im willing to take im expecting breakout)
Knights
Prestia
(Smith, Richardson, Tapscott) I might chuck Tapscott in their

So as u can see i can either upgrade Petrie or i couldup grade maybe polec and get another decent mid.
Like i have done with ur teams could u please rate and comment thanks :)

this is a pain to read!