Heath shaw vs Josh Hunt

[Jimm09]

I was thinking about trading Mr average (Hunt) up to inconsistent d!ckface (shaw). What do you reckon?

My team is solid and Hunt is my only weak spot but I'm a bit low on trades too but its tempting cos I know shaw can bust out but hunt cant

[hardnut]

is this for the 7th back spot or good cover.
If Hunt is on the field it's time to do something but it woud be better if you can do it and keep Hunt. I'd go Grimes or Harbrow over Shaw and they're not too expensive

[Jimm09]

Its for 7th :-[ bench is strijk and campbell heath

[Master Q]

Is Duffield in the price range, much better option.

[browny_wce]

is this for the 7th back spot or good cover.
If Hunt is on the field it's time to do something but it woud be better if you can do it and keep Hunt. I'd go Grimes or Harbrow over Shaw and they're not too expensive

+1 spesh if ur looking at a 7th back, shaw wuld be great for bench cover
grimes more consistent
how much cash u on?

[Master Q]

The Price Range Is What We Need To Know.

Grimes or Duffield over Shaw for me.

[McRooster]

1.The Cats play 3 top 8 side in the last 4 rounds.
   The Pies play 2 top 8 sides in the last 4 rounds.

    Pick Shaw.

2.The Cats play West Coast in the last round.
    The Pies play Hawthorn in the last round.

    Pick Shaw. (Hunt had 58 v Eagles, Shaw had 111 v Hawks)

3. B/E Shaw = 56 (22 BELOW average)
    B/E Hunt  = 81 (21 ABOVE average)

   Pick Shaw.

4.Hunt season high score 91.
   Shaw season high score 143.

   Pick Shaw.

5. Shaw, some weeks I wanna boof him and some weeks I wanna biff him but I enjoy the thrill of not knowing what I'm going to get.
   Hunt, you know pretty much what you're going to get.

   Pick Shaw. ;D

[Master Q]

1. Duffield is Duffield.

Pick Duffman over Shaw!

2. Grimes is Grimes.

Pick Grimes Over Shaw!

I think I won that battle ;D

[Prospector_1]

RickShaw?

[Master Q]

Duffman: Aveages 90
Grimes: Averages 83

Shaw: Averages 78.

[McRooster]

1. Duffield is Duffield.

Pick Duffman over Shaw!

2. Grimes is Grimes.

Pick Grimes Over Shaw!

I think I won that battle ;D

Yes Q, but for the simple fact of the topic title ???
Just to be Shaw...

Pick Shaw (as opposed to Hunt) ;)

[Master Q]

Alright. You Won That Battle. But I Won The Other One. But I Will Win The Next Battle, Which Will Be A Huge Battle Bigger Then The Other Battle and The Battle I Called "That Battle". I You Up For The Next Battle, Or Are You Already In Another Battle. Lets Battle.

I used "Battle" 9 Times in that Battle Speech. Beat that ;D

[McRooster]

Agreed you won the OTHER battle and that I won THIS battle but THE battle won't be decided here today. This battle is destined to fought in the battle arena of the forum herewith.
If I choose to take on this battle I do so by stating I'm a lover not a fighter, an advisor not a despiser, nervously ready for the trench warfare of battle. A battle to advise on trade cattle, not one to personally rattle battle.
We are "here to help" as you say so let's play...let's BATTLE.

P.s. That's 10, +1 to me! ;D

PICK SHAW!

[Prospector_1]

RICKSHAW!

[Jimm09]

Alright. My stinky backline is:

Hodge, Goddard, Duffman, Hargrave, HUNT, Waters, Maguire.

about 300k to spend

I assure you the rest of my team is good. I think I'll grab shaw. unless I pike and get grimes. Rooster u make it sound so fun